If you’re facing criminal charges, one of the first strategic decisions you’ll make with your defense attorney is whether to negotiate a plea bargain or take your case to trial. While plea agreements resolve roughly 90% of U.S. criminal cases, the bargaining process is nuanced. Let’s examine how skilled criminal justice lawyers leverage their expertise to negotiate advantageous plea deals for their clients.
Understanding Why Prosecutors Offer Pleas
To secure justice, prosecutors must balance punishing offenders, protecting victims, and using limited resources wisely. Negotiating plea bargains serves several pragmatic purposes for the state:
- Avoiding costs of a trial
- Sparing victims from testifying
- Quickly resolving open cases to clear dockets
- Securing at least a baseline conviction they can “count”
Prosecutors also understand that even strong cases carry risk. Witnesses can falter or juries may acquit. Removing uncertainty through mutually agreeable pleas keeps conviction rates high.
Knowing When to Pursue a Plea Bargain
Experienced defense attorneys don’t default to plea agreements. They objectively assess the particular strengths and weaknesses of the prosecutor’s case, the evidence against you, possible trial outcomes, your background, plus other factors.
If major holes exist that create reasonable doubt, they’ll typically advise fighting the charges at trial. However, if the case against you looks air tight, skilled negotiators use that leverage to bargain for a favorable deal in your best interest.
Negotiation Strategies and Approaches
Your attorney doesn’t just accept whatever initial offer the D.A. proposes. Savvy lawyers employ strategic approaches to secure optimal plea terms. Common techniques include:
- Citing mitigating circumstances that warrant mercy. This may involve highlighting extenuating life challenges you’ve overcome.
- Questioning legitimate public interest served by maximum penalties, based on your minimal criminal history and positive character references.
- Proposing creative sentencing alternatives to fines or prison time. This could involve vocational training, counseling, community service, etc.
- Leveraging their heavier caseloads and eagerness to avoid trial against prosecutors. Playing hardball carries risks, so attorneys walk a fine line to extract concessions without spurring push back.
- Taking a collaborative approach and framing the bargain as a “win-win.” Your lawyer positions the deal as a fair resolution that benefits both sides.
Typical Negotiation Goals
Though every case is unique, common plea bargaining objectives typically include:
- Reducing felony charges to misdemeanors to avoid lasting criminal record impacts
- Minimizing or eliminating jail/prison time and seeking alternative sentencing options
- Getting charges dropped completely from your record via deferred prosecutions or diversion programs
- Avoiding costly fines and limiting financial penalties imposed
- Preserving certain civil rights impacted by a criminal conviction
Considering Long-term Impacts
The immediate ramifications of a plea deal aren’t the only consideration. Savvy lawyers also negotiate with an eye toward avoiding unintended future consequences. These could include:
- Protecting professional licensure that could be revoked following certain convictions
- Preventing immigration pitfalls leading to deportation for non-citizens
- Maintaining access to student loans and public housing
- Preserving gun ownership and voting rights
Navigating Plea Hearings
Once a deal is struck, your attorney will guide you through the plea hearing process. They’ll explain exactly what you need to do, say, and prepare for when formally entering your negotiated guilty plea before the court.
Skilled lawyers also clarify how the deal becomes official and locks in the bargained terms after the court accepts your plea. They walk you through fulfilling sentencing terms like paying fines, attending counseling, completing community service, etc. to successfully close out the case.
In summary, securing a favorable plea requires much more than just signing boilerplate plea paperwork drafted by the prosecutor. With an experienced criminal defense attorney negotiating aggressively on your behalf, you can potentially resolve charges through a mutually beneficial plea bargain tailored to your specific situation.
Here are two more paragraphs added to the end of the blog post:
Even after a plea deal is reached, skilled criminal defense lawyers keep working on your behalf. They ensure proper procedures are followed, your legal rights are protected, and the negotiated terms are imposed as agreed.
Your attorney will advise you on next steps after the plea, which may involve completing probation requirements, paying restitution, or taking rehabilitation classes. They can also explore record expungement options available down the road to remove the plea from your criminal history. Having an attentive lawyer guiding you through each phase provides crucial peace of mind as you put the criminal case behind you.
The plea bargaining and hearing process involves many moving parts. An experienced criminal justice attorney from Benjamin Durham Law Firm leverages their expertise to secure favorable plea terms, properly enter your admission of guilt before the court, and ensure you successfully fulfill the deal’s requirements. With strong legal guidance, plea agreements can produce positive outcomes for defendants facing criminal accusations.